Forums for the Business Analyst

 
  Modern Analyst Forums  Business and Sy...  Vertical Domain...  How to develop Evaluation Criteria based on BRD.
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
New Post 11/19/2010 12:05 AM
User is offline srikanth
33 posts
9th Level Poster


How to develop Evaluation Criteria based on BRD. 

Hi,

I have prepared business requirements document which is signed off and sent to the shortlisted suppliers. I requested the suppliers to provide information how their solution meet our requirements. If satisfied, we shall invite them for a product demo. Now,

1) How should I prepare evaluation criteria before looking at the product demo.

2) Imagine, if suppliers havn't provided sufficient (Means just give brouchers or not provided any comments on each requirement etc..) and they are ready for product demo-how would I evaluated?

Please suggest....

Thank you.

Regards,

Srikanth.

 

 
New Post 11/19/2010 2:00 PM
User is offline Jarett Hailes
155 posts
6th Level Poster




Re: How to develop Evaluation Criteria based on BRD. 
Modified By Jarett Hailes  on 11/19/2010 5:00:50 PM)

Hi Srikanth,

1) If your BRD is not already in an itemized format, I would extract all the requirements from the document and put them into a list.  Look at your requirements list and for each requirement ask yourself "if I added a question mark to the end of each sentence, can I provide a yes or no answer to the question?".  For requirements that can't be easily answered, review those descriptions and modify them so that you can have a clear answer.  Voila!  You now have your evaluation criteria.  Add two columns to the right: one for the yes/no checkbox and one for a 'notes/details' section where you can write additional information or qualifications on the yes/no answer.

2) Before scheduling a product demo, I would tell your vendors to fill out the checklist you've created above.  Then the product demo can be focused on having the vendor show you how the application addresses each requirement they indicated their product can meet, as opposed to becoming a marketing/sales driven meeting.  If you have too many requirements to review in one meeting, focus on the most important and/or ones that differentiate the solution from others you are evaluating.  Once they've proven they can meet the requirement, move on to the next one on your list.  This way you're in control of the meeting instead of the other way around.

Jarett

 
New Post 11/22/2010 5:25 AM
User is offline srikanth
33 posts
9th Level Poster


Re: How to develop Evaluation Criteria based on BRD. 

Thank you.

Regards,

Srikanth.

 

 
New Post 11/25/2010 1:37 AM
User is offline Kimbo
450 posts
5th Level Poster


Re: How to develop Evaluation Criteria based on BRD. 
Modified By Kimbo  on 11/25/2010 4:37:49 AM)

 Hi Srikanth,

Good advice from Larimar. Something else to consider as well is to put priorities  against your requirements. Some will be must have deal breakers and some will be nice to haves that you don't really care that much about... and some will be somewhere in between. If you assign numbers to them (give them weightings based on their importance) you can end up with a final score for each vendor.  

A note of caution on all this. I worked on a large vendor evaluation project where we did all these good things. Spent many man months working on the evaluation. We thought we did well and under the terms of reference we were given, we did. Then a lady joined the project who started to question the premise on which the whole evaluation was based. She caused a lot of trouble and was assassinated professionally and ostracised by the project team. She stuck to her guns and was ultimately proved correct. I learnt a lot from that. Guess my point is, don't get hung up on the process and continue to question everything. Stick to your guns if you think you're right too. Her main message  was to be clear about where you want to go - your future state - and make sure that what your are evaluating and the way you are evaluating it will get you there.

Kimbo

 
New Post 11/29/2010 3:14 AM
User is offline Craig Brown
560 posts
www.betterprojects.net
4th Level Poster




Re: How to develop Evaluation Criteria based on BRD. 

 Something else you can add to these models is weighted scoring.  (eg 5 points for something that contributes to revenue, 3 points for cost reduction, etc)

And trace the feature requests back to the business case goals.

 
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
  Modern Analyst Forums  Business and Sy...  Vertical Domain...  How to develop Evaluation Criteria based on BRD.

Community Blog - Latest Posts

So you’ve found the perfect time and place to study and you’re ready to finally get some work done. You’ve pulled out your laptop, your textbook, and your notes, and four different highlighters. After five minutes of reading your textbook, you start zoning out and thinking about puppies. Then, you go on Tumblr and look at cut...
Elicitation involves bringing out or drawing out information. Elicitation is a key task in business analysis as without proper elicitation the requirements for the solution to the business needs cannot be identified. 1. Not understanding underlying business need Organization’s business environment keeps changing with respect to Customer...
TOGAF is a certification that is handed over by The Open Group. It is an open corporate architecture means used to improvise upon the business effectiveness across the world’s leading business set-ups. Aspirants wishing for a successful career in corporate architecture must go for the TOGAF certification in order to explain the...

 



 

Copyright 2006-2021 by Modern Analyst Media LLC