Forums for the Business Analyst

 
  Modern Analyst Forums  Business and Sy...  Structured Anal...  emergent design/ emerging requirements (An Agile question)
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
New Post 10/18/2008 2:38 AM
User is offline Craig Brown
560 posts
www.betterprojects.net
4th Level Poster




emergent design/ emerging requirements (An Agile question) 
Modified By Craig Brown  on 10/18/2008 4:52:36 AM)

Hello Modern Analysts,

By now you ave all heard of Agile software development.  you are probably ware that there are several frameworks and processes that fall within the umbrella of Agile, and some of them are quite distinct from one another.

One of the common themes in agile software discussions is the idea of emergent design and emerging requirements.

The simple idea is this: You can't know everything up front.  Also, things change and so in a 24 month or even 6 month project business needs have shofted since the beginning of the project.  Development teams should accomodate this.  And lastly (this is the theme of the question) planned design usually does no better than unplanned design.

I need to qualify this - I am excluding super large, national, cross organisational or international projects from this discussion.  Those babies are way complex and need a whole new set of rules beyond what agile can provide.

Now - back to the question;

Have you got an opinion on the premise that emergent design works as well as planned design?  Have you got a story about emergening design/requirements working or failing?

Please share.

 
New Post 10/18/2008 2:50 AM
User is offline Guy Beauchamp
257 posts
www.smart-ba.com
5th Level Poster




Re: emergent design/ emerging requirements (An Agile question) 

Hi Craig,

I have an opinion but you probably know it by now! One thing I do like is that "Emergent design" does sound better than "make it up as we go along"!

I have loads of stories about projects failing to do analysis failing - but you are talking about design so I guess they don't count ?

Guy

 

 
New Post 10/18/2008 2:54 AM
User is offline Craig Brown
560 posts
www.betterprojects.net
4th Level Poster




Re: emergent design/ emerging requirements (An Agile question) 

Guy

I am interested in the point at which the requirements failed.  At the system specification level or at the business knowing what they wanted level?

My hunch is the latter. Or if not, then the project team not bothering to find ot the business context and goals.

 
New Post 10/18/2008 3:01 AM
User is offline Guy Beauchamp
257 posts
www.smart-ba.com
5th Level Poster




Re: emergent design/ emerging requirements (An Agile question) 

 craigwbrown wrote

Guy

I am interested in the point at which the requirements failed.  At the system specification level or at the business knowing what they wanted level?

My hunch is the latter. Or if not, then the project team not bothering to find ot the business context and goals.

Craig,

It is unlikely that the business know what they want: our primary job as BAs is to use analysis to get them to analyse what they want, then challenge, then refine, then come to a better (true?) understanding of what they want BEFORE we go to design - as this saves so much time and cost (see Chaos report et al).

Failure to do this results in the question of what they really want just being shoved down the SDLC which means far more rework as what they really want emerges and so in response we have Agile...

Guy

 
New Post 10/18/2008 4:00 AM
User is offline Craig Brown
560 posts
www.betterprojects.net
4th Level Poster




Re: emergent design/ emerging requirements (An Agile question) 
Modified By Craig Brown  on 10/18/2008 6:04:08 AM)

Guy

What I mean here is - Are the business requirements & project scope/goals okay, aligned to strategy, sensible, practical etc?

Or is the system spec too complicated and too full of constraints?  Is the systejm specifiaction disassociated from the business objectives?

At which of these two scenarios are we most likely to find critical requirement failure?

 
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
  Modern Analyst Forums  Business and Sy...  Structured Anal...  emergent design/ emerging requirements (An Agile question)

Community Blog - Latest Posts

Salesforce has established itself as one of the most reputable CRM platforms, providing important customer data to assist businesses in effectively managing their operations. Salesforce is the world's best CRM platform that helps businesses to keep up the data in an arranged or structured manner. Salesforce is the world's most popular...
There are big differences between data exploration versus data presentation. And you need to be aware of these differences as you're creating data stories and data presentations. Let’s start by defining our terms: Data exploration means the deep-dive analysis of data in search of new insights. Data presentation means...
Is Agile a reason to avoid documentation? I bet this question shows up again and again while working with product requirements. On one side, we have got long specifications, complicated diagrams, mystical technical design, too many prototypes and pretty obvious for engineers user guides (do we really need so much?). On the other side, can we actual...

 






 

Copyright 2006-2022 by Modern Analyst Media LLC