Forums for the Business Analyst

 
  Modern Analyst Forums  Business and Sy...  Agile Analysis ...  Permission-Based Roles in User Stories
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
New Post 6/19/2016 9:16 PM
Unresolved
User is offline Mister Octopus
1 posts
No Ranking


Permission-Based Roles in User Stories 

Hi there. Forgive me for a potentially newbish question (I'm just starting out in the world of analysis):

With user stories, I know that it's good practice to give your "As a user..." section a specific role or persona to help explain the context of the user story. I'm currently writing user stories for a system where we have a handful of different roles who all have different viewing/editing permissions throughout the system. Most of these permissions cross over between the roles, so I'm wondering how to approach the user stories. Obviously, I don't want something that looks like:

"As an administrator, team manager or operator, I want to be able to..."

What is the best way to approach this? Do I just repeat the same story for each role? Do I use a generic "As a user with the correct permissions, I want..."?

Currently I have these stories simplified to "As a user, I want..." and then I have a final story that says:

"As the system, I must only allow users to perform actions as defined by their role permissions."

Is this an acceptable way to go about this, or am I approaching this whole concept wrong?

Thanks in advance!

 
New Post 6/20/2016 3:54 PM
User is offline NitWitNick
244 posts
6th Level Poster


Re: Permission-Based Roles in User Stories 
A User Story Alone Is Really Not Enough ...


A User Story quickly states what the user wants to do with the system at a high level ... So, "As a user...", is a very short description of a feature needed by a user.

And

A User story Does NOT replace Detailed requirements. A user story is basically used as pointer to those detailed requirements ... and it is hard to define both functional and non-functional details by just a user story.


Don't Get Hung Up On Thinking You Will Just Write User Stories ... You Need Detailed Stuff To Develop From ...

 

As I stated Before ... I do consulting and have Never seen a 100% Waterfall or a 100% Agile environment ... most are a Hybrid of various stuff.

 
New Post 3/2/2017 5:17 AM
User is offline sutnarcha
7 posts
10th Level Poster


Re: Permission-Based Roles in User Stories 

Agreeing with NitWitNick by-and-large, I want to add the below...

I always write user stories like "As a user with permission to xxxx...", and who has permission or what role has permission to xxxx... is a different reference document.

 
New Post 4/17/2017 8:26 AM
User is offline Patrick Schmöllerl
3 posts
No Ranking


Re: Permission-Based Roles in User Stories 

As you have already guessed, it is not always wise to describe everything in a user-story-like fashion. Every method has its use and purpose.

In a way it depends on the set-up of your project and your responsibilities, but what I like to do when describing the more detailed impact of permissions and roles is these 3 steps:

- Describe the user-story in a way: "As an administrator, I want ... " so the idea of who should be allowed to do what is commonly understood.
- Add a more detailed description for development in the form of: "IF the user does NOT have the permission xyz, THEN ..."
- Add a very seperate and standardized work-item for the user-administration or whoever does that in your organisation: "Add permission X to role Y. Add permission X to role Z. And in case the set-up allows it: Add role Y to user Patrick", etc.

 

 
New Post 5/11/2017 12:38 AM
User is offline Kimbo
422 posts
5th Level Poster


Re: Permission-Based Roles in User Stories 

Dear Occy

Another suggestion: write your user story 'As a user I want etc'. Then in your acceptance criteria write a series of scenarios for each role. I use gherkin from the BDD camp to specify scenarios for acceptance criteria. Works well

Kimbo

 

 
Previous Previous
 
Next Next
  Modern Analyst Forums  Business and Sy...  Agile Analysis ...  Permission-Based Roles in User Stories

Community Blog - Latest Posts

EA Learning
EA Learning
I recently walked into a large shopping centre on a mission to buy a christening present for a friends son. I was very clear on what I wanted I just needed to find it… I was on my lunch break so I need to get the job done as I had a meeting that I needed to attend back in the office straight after lunch! I am not a frequent shopper and to b...
0 Responses
BusinessAnalysisHub
BusinessAnalysisHub
Have you woken up in the middle of night thinking how am I going to steer my team, give them the direction that they need but at the same time not constraint in what they want to build/deliver. I recently went through one of these night- I have joined an interesting project where we have very tight timescale to deliver a tech product to operational...
0 Responses
Peter
Peter
If you are building a reusable Security Product tool to specifically address Security Technical Implementation Guide (STIG)  Findings, should the requirements be considered Non Functional Requirements or Functional Requirements? For example if there are a number of STIGs such as: The minimum password length shall be 15 characters ...
1 Responses


Upcoming Live Webinars



Latest Articles

The Elevator Speech... for the BA
Nov 12, 2017
2 Comments
A BA walks into an elevator, is joined by an executive, and suddenly the executive asks the BA, “So, what are you working on these days?” ...
Featured Digital Library Resources 
Copyright 2006-2015 by Modern Analyst Media LLC